For a guest lecture once at Pacific Lutheran University, I compiled a list of interviewing techniques for journalism students. The key lesson that topped them all was this:
Do not lie. Be smart enough to figure out how to get the story without deception.
Being upfront has saved me embarrassment many times in my career — whether it’s when an e-mail I wrote was forwarded up some chain and back to my boss, or, whether it was when I found myself questioned by authorities about my intentions.
In each case, I could say that I had honestly represented myself at all times. (Phew!)
Intellectual honesty is a virtue, I think, in any profession. It is particularly necessary for anyone working in the information business, and that’s nearly everyone these days! All we have to go on is our integrity. It’s not worth blowing it, even for a seemingly harmless white lie.
Now: You should have a healthy skepticism of anyone who would blog about how honest he or she is, in life or her job. So, instead of bragging to you about how awesome it is to work honestly, let me tell you about the time I screwed up, and got schooled in front of my peers in this regard.
In college, I majored in computer information systems and only discovered as a junior that I absolutely loved reporting. I felt as if my career were seriously behind my peers who had known what they wanted to do since age six, and so, I jumped at any head start I could get.
My first head start came via an exclusive class taught at The Washington Post, for journalism majors. I applied to the program and was amazed when I got in despite my major.
Each Friday, select students from Howard University, George Washington University and American University (my undergrad alma mater), got to learn one-on-one from the pros at the Post.
One particular Friday was Bob Woodward day. (Who’s Bob Woodward? Wikipedia.)
Instead of talking about his accomplishments, as I’d expected he would, he did a Socratic method exercise with us instead.
“Imagine,” he said, “It’s early in the morning at the Washington Post. You’re a young and hungry journalist, so you got in early. All of a sudden, the metro editor transfers a call to you. There’s someone on the line, a woman, and she sounds frantic. She says, ‘There’s been an anthrax outbreak and they’re taking the victims to GWU Hospital.’ And then she hangs up.”
Woodward posed this question to all of us: “What do you do?”
The students went around the board room with their ideas. Call the health inspector. Call the mayor’s office. Call the hospital.
I piped in, “Run to the drug store, buy a face mask and get down to that hospital.”
“Yes!” Woodward said.
(Of course, I was feeling quite proud that I gave the gutsy, and apparently correct, answer. My victory, however, was short lived.)
He looked at me, and continued the story. “Ok, you go into the hospital waiting room and you see people sitting around. Some look sick. There’s some bustle and then you realize that they are closing the entrance. You were one of the last people to get into the hospital. It’s now sealed off. What do you do?”
What would I do? I had no idea. “Duck into the bathroom!” I said.
“Ok,” Woodward continues. “Now you’re in the bathroom. There’s a nurse in there and she looks frightened. What do you do?”
“Ask her if there’s been an anthrax outbreak,” I said.
Woodward: “She turns to you and asks, ‘Who are you?'”
My mind raced. I felt trapped. I answered, “Say, ‘I’m here with my dad, who broke his leg.'”
Woodward stared hard at me. “You would lie?”
Crap. Wrong answer.
“Well, I didn’t want to tell her I was a reporter right away,” I explained.
“What’s your name?” he asked.
“Andrea,” I said.
He said, “Ok then. You respond, ‘I’m Andrea.'”
Me, incredulous it was that simple: “That’s it?”
Woodward: “That’s it. And when asked, always identify yourself as a reporter. Always.”
This lesson against deception is one that I never forgot, and carry with me to this day. Thanks, Bob.
By the way: If you ever happen to be a reporter trapped in a hospital during an anthrax outbreak, the proper next step is to call your editor. At that point, the news outlet is going to want to get more bodies on the story.
Oh, and proof that this exchange actually happened, or at least as much proof as I can muster. Here’s a photo from that day in spring 2003:
Nice post, Andrea! Great example. I have my own story of how I screwed up on this score in college, and it was way worse than a Socratic exercise. But your bottom line is right on: If asked, you identify yourself as a journalist.
Rob: You must share!
Andrea, did you really think some readers might not know who Woodward is? Or was that tongue-in-cheek?
Mike, I linked to be tongue-in-cheek, but also on the off chance someone didn’t know. I’ve got some readers from other industries besides journalism.
As an aside: I don’t think public education in history is all that great. In this year’s election, kids born in 1992 could vote. (!!) And, unless they’re politically engaged, or have a good command of the Nixon era, they might not know of him.
That said: You’re right, my blog readership would all likely know!
Love this story! And love how you wrote it, with all the quotes 🙂 AND, love that my former next-desk-over-colleague Snyder reads your blog!
Such an interesting story & you definitely have a reporters instincts. While I’m not surprised, I’m nonetheless impressed that Woodward makes a point of lecturing – or leading discussions – at classes like the one you attended. I think it shows how passionate he is about journalism.(& btw, Woodward’s ’05 acct of how he came to the WP is riveting – he too had an unconventional background http://j.mp/dkZjdk (“How Mark Felt Became Deep Throat”)
Oh & you saw this, right? http://goo.gl/YaiWq “Woodward, Bradlee and The Post’s iPad app”
Thanks Lexi! Means a lot coming from a real author!
Awesome HMF! I heard about it but only now just watched it. LOVE IT. HAHA he’s on a typewriter. …Also HMF, I replied to a comment you wrote a few posts back, with a question about your relative in Palestine.
peculiar pics
Love this post!
Marvelous lesson. I’m forwarding this to a friend who teaches journalism.
I’m glad you shared this.
Thank you @pop, @Emily and @Vince. 🙂 Vince, I hope it helps the class! 🙂